Before Referring a Gifted Child for ADD/ADHD Evaluation
Print Friendly
Author Sharon Lind Citation Copyright © 1996 Sharon Lind. Reprinted with the permission of the author.

Before Referring a Gifted Child for ADD/ADHD Evaluation

Parents and gifted educators are asked with increased frequency to instruct gifted children to conform to a set of societal standards of acceptable behavior and achievement — to smooth the edges of the square peg in order to fit into a “normal” hole. Spontaneity, inquisitiveness, imagination, boundless enthusiasm, and emotionality are being discouraged to create calmer, quieter, more controlled environments in school. An extension of this trend is reflected in an increase in referrals for medical evaluation of gifted children as ADD/ADHD (Attention Deficit Disorder/Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder). There is no doubt that gifted children can be ADD/ADHD. However, there are also gifted children whose “inappropriate behavior” may be a result of being highly gifted and/or intense.

This intensity coupled with classroom environments and curriculum which do not meet needs of gifted, divergent, creative, or random learners, may lead to the mislabeling of many children as ADHD. To avoid mislabeling gifted children, parents and educators may want to complete the following check list to help them decide to refer for medical or psychological evaluation.


Gifted?
Need More Information
ADD/ADHD?
Contact with intellectual peers diminishes inappropriate behavior o Contact with intellectual peers has no positive effect on behavior
Appropriate academic placement diminishes inappropriate behavior o Appropriate academic placement has no positive effect on behavior
Curricular modifications diminish inappropriate behaviors o Curricular modifications have no effect on behavior
The child has logical (to the child) explanations for inappropriate behavior o Child cannot explain inappropriate behavior
When active, child enjoys the movement and does not feel out of control o Child feels out of control
Learning appropriate social skills has decreased “impulsive” or inappropriate behavior o Learning appropriate social skills has not decreased “impulsive” or inappropriate behavior
Child has logical (to the child) explanations why o Child is unable to explain why tasks, activities are not completed
Child displays fewer inappropriate behaviors when interested in subject matter or project o Child’s behaviors not influenced by his/her interest in the activity
Child displays fewer inappropriate behaviors when subject matter or project seems relevant or meaningful to the child o Child’s behaviors do not diminish when subject matter or project seems relevant or meaningful to the child
Child attributes excessive talking or interruptions on need to share information,  need to show that he/she knows the answer, or need to solve a problem immediately o Child cannot attribute excessive talking or interruptions to a need to learn or share information
Child who seems inattentive can repeat instructions o Child who seems inattentive is unable to repeat instructions
Child thrives on working on multiple tasks –  gets more done, enjoys learning more o Child moves from task to task for no apparent reason
Inappropriate behaviors are not persistent – seem to be a function of subject matter o Inappropriate behaviors persist regardless of subject matter
Inappropriate behaviors are not persistent – seem to be a function of teacher or instructional style o Inappropriate behaviors persist regardless of teacher or instructional style
Child acts out to get teacher attention o Child acts out regardless of attention

If, after addressing these questions, parents and teachers believe that it is not an unsuitable, inflexible, or unreceptive educational environment which is causing the child to “misbehave” or “tune out,” or if the child feels out of control, then it is most certainly appropriate to refer a gifted child for ADD/ADHD diagnosis. Premature referral bypasses the educational system and takes control away from students, parents and educators. By referring before trying to adjust the educational environment and curriculum, educators appear to be denouncing the positive attributes of giftedness and/or to be blaming the victim of an inappropriate educational system.

When deciding to refer, parents should search for a competent diagnostician who has experience with both giftedness and attention deficit disorders. It is never appropriate for teachers, parents or pediatricians to label a child as ADD or ADHD without comprehensive clinical evaluation that can distinguish ADD/ADHD from look-alike with other causes.

No Comments

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.


Connect with the SENG Community: Facebook Twitter